Michael
Hillman
A few years after purchasing our farm, I have found
myself playing detective in what has increasingly become
a fascinating and engrossing trek through the history of
the lands along Sixes Bridge, Dern, and Four Points
Roads, which form the drainage basin for a creek called Stony
Branch. The more I began to uncover about
the history of the land, the more I began to wonder
about the people that once lived on the vast family
farms which occupied much of the land south and east of
Emmitsburg. The more I discovered, through literary
research, interviews, and hacks through the countryside,
the more I realized how much history of this valley has
gone untold and, in many cases, unrecorded.
It all started off as a simple story. It was
Christmas Eve and I was enjoying a warm fire in my
study, which at one time, years ago, served as a summer
kitchen. For the prior few weeks, I had been working on
a mantle piece, which was intended to be the finishing
touch to a yearlong restoration effort. Made out of old
fence boards, the mantle was meant to symbolize that
everything, no matter how old, could still serve a
purpose.
That evening, as I sat and admired the reflection of
the flames off of the old books in the bookcases, I
decided that a story on the history of the room would be
interesting to do. The story quickly grew to encompass
all the restoration work that Audrey and I had done on
the house over the past few years. As I was writing, it
occurred to me that I knew more about the history of the
Bridge over Tom's Creek, or for that matter, the Roman
Empire, then I knew about my own house.
According to bits and pieces of stories I have heard,
the house was once the tenant house for the old
Bollinger family farm and it was built some time around
the turn of the century. Curiosity soon got the better
of me and the day after Christmas I found myself in the
records room of the county court house looking up past
deeds on the property. With a lot of help from Bonny
Fuss, I was able to trace the ownership of the farm back
through five previous owners, to the 1940's. There, much
to my surprise, I discovered a deed of transfer showing
that the farm had not always been one lot, but was made
up of three small lots, each with its own distinct
history.
As I went a further back in history, I discovered
that the names I have become so familiar with, i.e., the
Wivells, the Valentines, the Zurgables,
were never mentioned. Instead the records spoke of
unknown families bearing such names as the Zacharias,
the Weltys,
the Stansburys, and the Maxwells. Unlike present deeds
that contain only facts related to degrees, feet and
acres, deeds written in the 17th and 18th century
provide a glimpse into the past, often referring to the
circumstances surrounding the property transfer and
almost always to the names of neighboring farms and
their owners.
As I soon discovered, at the turn of the 18th
century, the plateau which our farm occupies and the
valley it overlooks were divided into four major farms:
to the west was Alta Vista, to the north, Diggs' Lot, to
the east, Delight, and to the south, Single Delight.
Surrounding these farms were older farms from which they
had been broken off, farms with names such as Brotherly
Love, Whiskey Bottle, Benjamin
Good Luck, and Buck's Forest.
While the original deeds noted the dimensions of each
of these farms, their exact placement in the valley
eluded me. Like all mysteries however, seemingly
insignificant comments turn out to be major clues, as
was the case when my neighbor, Rick Yinger, remarked
while looking at an outline of 'Single
Delight' that it looked remarkably like a
diagram on his deed. Sure enough, his deed contained a
plot of his farm, superimposed over the 1940 boundaries
of 'Single Delight'. Much to my surprise, and relief,
the boundaries of 'Single Delight' had not changed much
since its founding in 1762.
Later, Joe Wivell Jr., while looking over an 1809
diagram of 'Whiskey Bottle', remarked that it looked
remarkably like a section of his father’s present day
farm. Sure enough, when the old deed were superimposed
over a diagram of the present day Wivell farm, most of
the original 17 century boundary lines matched up
perfectly, and unchanged. Much like working a jigsaw
puzzle, I was able to plot out the exact locations of
the other original farms.
When the warm weather of early January descended upon
us, I availed myself of the pleasant weather, mounted my
horse and began to survey the land. Riding the original
boarders, I often found myself wondering what the
original farmers had seen and what made them decide to
settle in this valley. From the vantage point of a horse’s
back, like the first settlers, I was able to get a
perspective of the valley that one can never grasp while
driving in a car. Knowing that in the 1700’s,
boundaries of land were based primarily upon the
direction water flowed after a rain, the rationale for
the boarders of the original farms soon became apparent.
An unexpected, but pleasurable benefit of this effort
has been the discovery of little known or long forgotten
items of curiosity. For example, I discovered that the
little creek I have driven over for the past seven years
has a name - 'Beaver Creek' - and that it emptied into
'Stony Branch' a another creek which had been, up until
this time, nameless to me. I also discovered that on one
side of our house once stood the local one room public
school, which Emmitsburg resident Mary Krom attended,
and on the other side once stood a yellow house, torn
down in 1929, whose children were Mary's playmates.
My research also took me outside the confines of the
valley and I discovered stories about Confederates
passing through Emmitsburg (which was not a bastion of
Union Support), on their way to Gettysburg. Much to my
surprise, I discovered that Emmitsburg was where General
Mead had planned to fight Lee and that by fate alone
Emmitsburg escaped the onslaught Gettysburg received.
The deeper I got into this story, the stronger I
found the pull to write at least part of the history. I
say part, because the history of Emmitsburg is fairly
well documented from its beginning to about 1906 in a
book titled 'The History Of Emmitsburg' by Helman.
However, little of our rich history has been written
since then and, though it has not yet been lost, it
resides only in the memories of our fellow neighbors. I
developed a sense of urgency in my efforts to record the
history of the land and its people when I learned of Bob
Sailor's death. I had the great honor of interviewing
Bob just before Christmas and the wealth of knowledge he
freely gave to me has kept me occupied since then. I
regret deeply that I only scratched and recorded the
surface of the memories of probably the greatest man
Emmitsburg ever sired.
I have no idea how many months it will take to
accurately and effectively retell this valley's history.
But as was repeatedly stressed in the recent community
considerations over the fate of Four
Points Bridge, history is an important
link in our sense of community. Many, however, like
myself, whose careers have taken them far from their
roots, have few local connections from which we can
easily garner the rich unwritten stories about our
adopted hometown. Others, unfortunately, have simply
discounted too greatly the value of memories and
historical artifacts, thereby unintentionally exposing
them to the dust bin of history.
If this history is to come alive however, I will need
the help of everyone with tales of the past. No memory
is unimportant so, if you are willing to share yours,
please contact the newspaper and an interview will be
arranged. Also, since I am concentrating my efforts on
the lands and families located southeast of Emmitsburg,
collaboration with individuals living in Emmitsburg and
to the west or north will greatly enhance the scope,
quality and appeal of the resulting stories. If you are
interested in helping, please contact the Dispatch.
As this edition goes to print, I find that in spite
of extensive research, I have been able to uncover only
a limited amount of information on such key families and
individuals as the Stansburys - both Nicholas and Noah -
William and Mary A. M. Welt, Albert and Mary L. (Welt)
Valentine, the Forney's, the Whitman's, the Moser's, the
Maxwell's, the Marshall's and the Chalice’s. Any story
or lead on them, no matter how insignificant it may
seem, will be welcomed. Also any information or maps
related to Buck Forest, Frisk Dam, or Diggs' Lot would
also be appreciated. If all goes well, it is my
intention to begin the series in the April edition.