Non-Profit Internet Source for News, Events, History, & Culture of Northern Frederick & Carroll County Md./Southern Adams County Pa.

 

Taneytown History

Tales from the Oriolanders' diamond

David Buie

(4/2024) Years ago, during an annual spectacle, Taneytown would burst onto the professional baseball stage with sleek cars, impeccably dressed gentlemen, and boys proudly donning the Oriolanders emblem on their jerseys, captivating the crowd's gaze. Unbeknownst to many spectators, hidden among them were two budding talents destined for the professional leagues. Two more hometown heroes from Taneytown stood by, poised to join their ranks with hopeful anticipation.

The Oriolanders, a baseball team drawing talent from several states, including Maryland, Virginia, Pennsylvania, West Virginia, Delaware, and New York, served as a beacon for aspiring players in the late 20th century. The team was led by scout Jim Gilbert and engaged in a rigorous selection process, ultimately forming a squad that competed in approximately 50-weekend games. Only a few of the hundreds who vied for a spot, such as Billy Pulsipher and pitcher Matt White, earned coveted positions. While Pulsipher found his place in Major League Baseball (MLB), White's journey was marked by remarkable twists and unforeseen challenges.

Billy Pulsipher emerged as a standout player among Oriolanders, exhibiting exceptional talent that propelled him to the upper echelons of professional baseball. His career, spanning from 1995 to 2005, saw him don the jerseys of renowned teams like the New York Mets, Milwaukee Brewers, Boston Red Sox, Chicago White Sox, and St. Louis Cardinals. Initially hailed as a cornerstone of the Mets' heralded "Generation K," Pulsipher’s trajectory encountered impediments in the form of injuries, including a debilitating torn ulnar collateral ligament that necessitated surgical intervention. Moreover, battles with major depression and anxiety further complicated his journey, underscoring the multifaceted challenges faced by athletes striving for success at the highest level.

Contrasting Pulsipher’s tumultuous path, Matt White embarked on a journey fraught with trials and triumphs. A product of Waynesboro High School, White's baseball odyssey commenced in Taneytown, Maryland. Despite being selected seventh overall in the 1996 MLB draft by the San Francisco Giants, negotiations faltered, leading to White exploiting a little-known rule from 1990 to secure free agency. Under the guidance of his advisor, Scott Boras, White capitalized on this opportunity, clinching a record-breaking $10.2 million signing bonus from the Devil Rays.

White's meteoric rise, fueled by immense potential, captivated the baseball world. His professional debut in the New York-Penn League in 1997 showcased his prowess, amassing impressive statistics despite competing against older adversaries. However, subsequent seasons witnessed fluctuations in performance, indicative of the unpredictable nature of athletic pursuits. Despite receiving accolades from Baseball America for his formidable skill set, including a potent fastball and adept breaking ball, White grappled with inconsistency and injuries that hampered his progression.

As White traversed through various minor league tiers, glimpses of promise intermingled with setbacks. Despite a brief resurgence in 2000, highlighted by a commendable performance across Double-A and Triple-A levels, his aspirations of donning a major league jersey were marred by persistent shoulder issues. Subsequent surgeries and prolonged rehabilitation efforts failed to restore him to his former glory, culminating in his retirement in 2006, bereft of the opportunity to showcase his talent on the grand stage of MLB.

The journey of Oriolanders, epitomized by the trajectories of Billy Pulsipher and Matt White, underscores the unpredictable nature of athletic pursuits. While physical ailments and mental health struggles marred Pulsipher’s career, White's narrative epitomizes the precariousness of talent amidst the unforgiving landscape of professional sports. Their stories testify to the resilience, perseverance, and indomitable spirit of athletes who dare to dream amidst the uncertainty of their chosen vocation. As the baseball world continues to evolve, the legacies of Pulsipher and White endure as reminders of the sport's enduring allure and inherent challenges.

Though they never achieved a professional career, two native Taneytown standouts, Vince Stonesifer and Wes Peters, were asked to participate with the Oriolanders. In an article in the Baltimore Sun on October 18, 2018, the Sun noted that Stonesifer, 16, participated in a tryout camp in Hershey, last month and was chosen for the team. The Sun also noted that the Oriolanders play at Taneytown Memorial Park most weekends this month.

Stonesifer was also selected for the Mid-Atlantic Showcase Team, which the Orioles sponsored. He continued traveling to tournaments from Taneytown and Gettysburg, to Charlotte and Raleigh, N.C., and later played collegiate Division II baseball at Tusculum University in Tennessee.

Read other history articles by David Buie

Read other articles on Taneytown history